Situational variables affecting obedience
Milgram's research provided a platform for further research into the situational variables affecting obedience. Milgram conducted a number of variations of his original experiment to explore how factors, such as proximity, location, and uniform, affected the rate of obedience.
Â
PROXIMITY
The situational variable of proximity refers to how physically close or distant a person is to another person or object. Milgram's obedience study involved various levels of proximity, including the distance between the teacher and the learner and the distance between the teacher and the experimenter.
Â
To examine the influence of proximity on obedience, Milgram conducted a variation of the study where the teacher and learner were situated in the same room. In this variation, the percentage of participants administering the full 450 volts decreased from 65% to 40%. This suggests that obedience levels were lower when the teacher was in closer physical proximity to the learner, as the teacher could more directly perceive the learner's pain. Milgram also observed that when the experimenter was absent from the room and gave instructions over the phone, obedience levels dropped even further to 20.5%. This suggests that obedience levels are reduced when the proximity between the teacher and the authority figure is increased.
Â
LOCATION
Milgram's original research was conducted in a laboratory at Yale University. Milgram also conducted a variation of the study in a rundown building in Bridgeport, Connecticut, to test the power of location. In this variation, the percentage of participants who administered the full 450 volts decreased from 65% to 47.5%, demonstrating the importance of location in shaping an environment conducive to obedience.
Â
UNIFORM
Milgram investigated the impact of uniform on obedience by having the experimenter wear a white lab coat in most of his variations, which symbolised his authority as a university professor or scientist. However, in one variation, the experimenter was replaced by an ordinary-looking confederate in regular clothes. In this case, the percentage of participants who delivered the maximum 450 volts decreased significantly from 65% to 20%. This illustrates the influence that uniform has on obedience levels.
Â
Milgram's variations | Explanation | Situational variable | % |
Someone else administered the shock. | Agentic State | Â | 92.5% |
Milgram's Original Study | Â | Â | 65% |
The experiment took place in a rundown building, i.e. less prestigious environment | Legitimacy of authority | Location | 47.5% |
The teacher and learner were in the same room. | Â | Proximity (Learner) | 40% |
The experimenter gave instructions to the teacher over the phone. | Â | Proximity (Authority Figure) | 20.5% |
The experimenter was replaced by another 'participant' in ordinary clothes. | Legitimacy of authority | Uniform | 20% |
